Say “I do” to pasta perfection.
Which Ice Cream Maker is Right For You? Here’s Our Picks!
Frozen custard, gelato, sorbet, soft serve—whatever your favorite, there’s something deeply satisfying about scooping up your own homemade creation on a warm summer afternoon. And with an ice cream maker in your kitchen, that joy is always just a few ingredients away.
Whether you’re dreaming of churning out creamy vanilla for family night or experimenting with dairy-free fruit blends, the right machine can make all the difference. But with so many models, features, and formats available, it’s easy to get overwhelmed.
We’re here to help you sort it all out—how ice cream makers work, the different types, what to consider when choosing one, and the accessories that make the experience even sweeter. Plus, we’ve rounded up some of our favorite ice cream makers available now at Sur La Table.
Hungry for more? From scoops and spoons to ice cream starters, sprinkles and toppings, our Scoop Shop has everything you need for the perfect summer treat.
How Do Ice Cream Makers Work?
Most home ice cream makers operate by churning a mixture of ingredients while gradually freezing them. This process incorporates air (for that creamy texture) and prevents large ice crystals from forming. Depending on the model, freezing can be done via a pre-frozen bowl, built-in compressor or with rock salt and ice.
Types of Ice Cream Makers
Not all ice cream makers are created equal—and the best one for you depends on how often you plan to use it, how much space you have, and how hands-on you want to be. Here’s a quick look at the main types and what makes each one unique:
- Compressor Ice Cream Makers
These are the most convenient and high-performing models. They have a built-in freezer unit, so you can make batch after batch without pre-freezing. These are great for frequent use and serious ice cream lovers. - Freezer Bowl Ice Cream Makers
These require you to freeze the bowl for at least 12-24 hours before use. They’re more affordable and compact but require planning ahead. - Manual or Hand-Cranked Makers
A nostalgic and interactive option that uses a combination of ice and rock salt packed around a metal canister to freeze the mixture. As you crank the handle, the mixture churns and freezes at the same time. It takes more effort—but for many, that’s part of the charm. Best for occasional use, small batches or a fun family activity. - Stand Mixer Attachments
If you already own a compatible stand mixer, an ice cream maker attachment can be an efficient and space-saving way to churn frozen treats.
Which Ice Cream Maker is Right for You?
The best ice cream maker is the one that fits your lifestyle—and your freezer space. Here’s how to decide based on your habits, preferences and kitchen setup:
- The Frequent Entertainer
Love throwing backyard parties or hosting big family dinners? A compressor-style machine is your best bet. It chills on demand, so you can whip up batch after batch without waiting or re-freezing. It’s the go-to choice for serious dessert enthusiasts who want performance, convenience and the ability to experiment with multiple flavors in one day. - The Weekend Dabbler
If you’re just dipping your toe into the world of homemade ice cream, a freezer bowl model is perfect. It’s compact, easy to use and delivers reliably creamy results—as long as you remember to freeze the bowl ahead of time. They’re great for occasional use and smaller kitchens. - The Minimalist
Already own a stand mixer and don’t want to add another appliance to your countertop? A stand mixer attachment is an easy and efficient way to get started. It saves space, delivers solid results and is ideal for those who make frozen treats occasionally but still want that fresh-from-scratch flavor. - The Traditionalist
If your idea of summer fun includes hand-cranking ice cream with the kids or recreating old-fashioned recipes, a manual ice cream maker adds a sense of ritual to the experience. - The Flavor Experimenter
Like to try bold flavor combos, dairy-free bases, or add-ins galore? Look for a machine that offers precise controls and consistent freezing—like a compressor model with multiple settings. These machines give you flexibility to test and tweak your recipes with confidence. - The Budget-Conscious Buyer
You don’t need to spend a fortune to enjoy homemade ice cream. Freezer bowl models are widely available, reasonably priced, and can still produce scoop-shop-worthy results—especially when paired with high-quality ingredients.
Don’t Forget the Accessories
To elevate your ice cream experience, make sure you have the right ice cream tools:
- Ice cream starters and mixes: Save time and experiment with flavors.
- Ice cream bowls: Serve it up in style with bowls that keep your scoops chilled and your toppings intact.
- Whipped cream maker: Add the perfect finishing swirl with fresh whipped cream on demand—no cans required.
- Scoopers and spades: Look for ergonomic handles and non-stick surfaces.
- Storage containers: Keep your creations fresh with airtight, freezer-safe containers.
- Toppings and mix-ins: From sprinkles to syrups, have your favorites ready.
Our Top Picks for Home Ice Cream Makers
Whether you’re a first-time ice cream maker or a frozen dessert connoisseur, these ice cream machines make it easy to churn out something delicious. We’ve grouped them by style and standout features to help you find the best fit for your kitchen and taste buds.
Best Overall Premium: Lello Dream Ice Cream Machines
If you’re looking for top-tier design and performance, Lello’s machines deliver.
These sleek, modern ice cream makers come equipped with built-in compressors, touch controls, and thoughtful design details that make them as stylish as they are powerful. Great for serious home chefs or anyone who wants a more elevated experience.
Top Compressor Pick: Breville Smart Scoop
A self-refrigerating powerhouse with 12 hardness settings and a keep-cool function. Ideal for back-to-back batches and experimenting with textures—whether you want silky sorbet, chewy gelato or scoopable soft serve.
Best for Small Batches: Cuisinart One Pint Wonder
Perfect for quick cravings or single servings, this compact model makes just enough for one or two people—no leftovers, no waste.
Best Everyday Models: Cuisinart Freezer Bowl Lineup
These classic, freezer-bowl machines offer great value and consistent results. You’ll need to pre-freeze the bowl, but they’re reliable, easy to use and available in a few formats:
- Cool Creations: A stylish, straightforward model with intuitive controls.
- Pure Indulgence: Slightly larger (2-quart) capacity—great for families.
- Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker: The tried-and-true crowd favorite.
- Ice Cream & Gelato Maker: Includes two paddles to switch between creamy ice cream and dense Italian-style gelato.
Best for Kids and Soft Serve Fans: Cuisinart Mix-It-In Soft Serve
Churn up soft serve at home with this playful model that includes mix-in dispensers and a cone holder. It’s fun, interactive and great for parties.
Best Space-Saving Option: KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment
If you already own a KitchenAid stand mixer, this attachment transforms it into an ice cream maker without adding another appliance to your kitchen. Just freeze the bowl, attach the paddle and churn away.
Best for Instant Fun: Chef’n Sweet Spot Ice Cream Maker
No electricity, no waiting—just pour, mix and scrape.
This clever frozen plate lets you make individual servings of ice cream, frozen yogurt or rolled ice cream in minutes. Just freeze the base ahead of time, then add your ingredients and watch dessert come together right before your eyes. Great for kids, parties or experimenting with small batches.
Best for Storing and Scooping: Tovolo Glide-A-Scoop
Not a machine, but a must-have. This insulated tub keeps your ice cream fresh and easy to serve, with a clever design that fits neatly in your freezer and helps you get the perfect scoop every time.
Need a Homemade Ice Cream Recipe to Get Started?
Once you’ve picked your perfect machine, it’s time to start churning! Whether you’re craving a classic vanilla bean, rich chocolate custard or a fruity sorbet, having a go-to homemade ice cream recipe makes all the difference.
Check out our roundup of 11 homemade ice cream recipes to get inspired. You’ll find something for every palate—including no-churn options and dairy-free favorites—so you can make the most of your new machine right away.
Hungry for more? From scoops and spoons to ice cream starters, sprinkles and toppings, our Scoop Shop has everything you need for the perfect summer treat.
Join The Conversation